Category Archives: Class Warfare

Notes from the Hegemon

From morguefile.com http://www.morguefile.com/archive/display/180811

From morguefile.com http://www.morguefile.com/archive/display/180811

I remember when the planes hit the towers. I was a sophomore in high school in Academic Support, the euphemistic name the district gave study hall, making up a Global History quiz I missed. My teacher, Ms. Zalewski, turned on the TV. One of the World Trade Center towers was on fire. She was somber. I assumed it was an accident and was astonished that the plane couldn’t miss the building.

I went the band room for the second half to practice clarinet. Soon, I was the only person in the hall. My (to this day!) dear friend Laura pulled me out and told me a second plane hit the other tower. It was then that I, and maybe everyone else, realized it wasn’t an accident. I remember thinking, “Our turn.” See, I’d spent my youth watching coverage of bombs in the Balkans, bombs in Israel and Palestine, mines in Africa and Asia, bombs seemingly everywhere. Violence seemed to be the way of the world. I’ve never met anyone who also had this reaction.

My countrymen were scared. Isolated by oceans and protected by the strongest military in the world, this sort of attack struck everyone else as unfathomable. We reacted. Oh, did we react. We swiftly went to war and we’ve been at war ever since, about half my lifetime.

I watched as we traded civil liberties for a chance at that fleeting feeling of protection. I watched as a group I rarely thought about before – Muslims – suddenly became the denigrated group. I watched as people approximately my age joined the military and hearing about how some of them never came back. I watched as my country opened a detention center offshores, and then another, and then another despite violating war crimes ethics and conventions. I watched as so many of the values I was taught we had as a child were undone in the name of safety and security. Dissenters were unpatriotic. It became thought reasonable to judge an entire religion based on its extremists. White Christians who never apologized for Timothy McVeigh (who is from my area) demanded apologies from Muslims for 9/11, contributing and creating a conventional (if inaccurate) wisdom that Muslims are violent. The surveillance state grew, buoyed by technological advances and the support of a scared population. I felt like I’d lost my country a bit, that this sweet land of liberty was tip-toeing towards becoming a fear-driven police state.

Getting older has been a disenchanting process realizing that we are not now, nor never have been, as good as I thought. As governor after governor (and some of my local politicians) try to block Syrian refugees from settling in their states, I realize this: We’ve learned nothing. This is textbook, exactly what we did with the Jewish refugees and look what happened to them. The terror attacks in France were horrific, as terror attacks always are. Horrific and apparently effective, as politicians are now shifting their rhetoric because they are scared, because they sense their constituents are scared, and exploiting fear is politically profitable. Never mind that this is more or less the goal of Daesh/ISIS.

I had already written letters to several elected officials asking they increase the refugee quotas. I live in a depopulated city near many refugees. My next door neighbor was one. A couple families down the street are refugees. A few blocks over and there are many more refugees. Some of them are Muslim. I love where I live and I have the absolute best neighbors. Then I called the governor, called my Congressman with my telephone as it seemed every public figure on Facebook’s comments were filled with people asking to drive the refugees away. No, no, no, no, no…. not this again.

Listen, I’ve known people with Syrian heritage. Heck, I have kin with Syrian heritage! Some are Muslim. Some are Christian. One is Jewish. Syrians are not a monolith. Everything I know about the Syrian war is that it is absolutely brutal. I can’t read about it. I work on problems of profound human misery for a living and I cannot read about the Syrian War or ISIS/Daesh because it’s too bad for me to cope. I get nightmares for days. I give money to refugee agencies, but that is all I can do as an individual. I rely on forces more powerful than I to make wise decisions and here we are closing the door because of the chance – the chance! – that someone from Syria could cause us harm. The chance that someone born in our own country could cause us harm doesn’t inspire us to more strictly regulate our weapons. The fact that cars are the most likely thing to kill us hasn’t inspired most of us to trade in our keys for public transit. We’re more likely to die from overindulging in our dinners and forgetting to exercise than we are in a terror attack but Syrians are the real threat, and please pass the butter.

Refusing to be afraid is a political act. Walking home at night when you are a woman is a political act when everyone tells you that you are assault bait. Not being anxious going into a “bad” (read: usually Black and usually poor) neighborhood is a political act if you are a white person and your society is structured on fearing non-white people. There is this vein in our culture that anything is justifiable if it could protect us from the people we dislike, as if safety were paramount. It’s completely based on prejudice. Crimes rates have been dropping? Whatever. Immigrants commit fewer crimes? Forget it.

I’m so sick of reading comments on my local news websites written by people using the fanciest technology that humanity has ever known, sitting in the wealthiest country of the world, begrudging letting what ends up being relatively few people to their cushy sphere of prosperity because they don’t want their taxes dollars spent on them. Or because they are afraid of “those people”. “Can you justify the risk” I’ve read, over and over again, “that you or your loved ones might be the target of a terrorist who slips in?” We justify lots of risks all of the time. Yet, here, the risk of one person doing harm to us is so great that we should let hundreds of thousands of people die in the process, because we won’t trust an thorough federal government over our prejudices. We value our lives more than anyone else’s. All of our foreign policies boil down to that. We won’t give up our hegemonic position and we’ll kill or let die anyone who we think might threaten that.

We are no better than anyone else, but we certainly act as if our lives are. At the time when “All Lives Matter” is the preferred dismissive retort to those advocating for African American rights, we turn our backs on refugees and bomb the Middle East. All lives matter indeed.

I often think back to September 11, 2001, and mourn, “It could have been so different.” If only we we’d been, or could be now, a bit braver. I hold on to optimism that we could find courage from common humanity, that we could be so brave as to be the moral example, that we could be the model of ideal humanity. I cannot make that argument as we close our doors and use our powers and privileges to ruthlessly prioritize our own safety. I cannot make that claim as our elected leaders attempt to push out the vulnerable.

We could do better. May we be brave enough to live with moral courage, instead of deferring to the impulse of safety at all costs. All costs have been too expensive and it is not going to become cheaper.

11/18/15-edited for grammar and typos.

1 Comment

Filed under Class Warfare, Lessons Learned The Hard Way, Race, Social Justice Commentary

What does it mean when your state of emergency is a natural consequence of the economic system?

(Friendly reminder! I write my opinions here, and this blog doesn’t represent the agency that I work for. Got it? Good. Carry on.)

The mayor of Seattle, Ed Murray, and the executive of King County, Dow Constantine, declared a state of emergency regarding homelessness in Seattle and King County. From The Seattle Times:

Murray called homelessness in Seattle a growing crisis among the worst in the city’s history, while Constantine said the situation countywide is “just as devastating to thousands as flood or fire.”

They aren’t lying. From the Seattle/King County Coalition on Homelessness:

ONC15-graphic-450

For comparison sake, Western New York (Erie and Niagara Counties) had almost 8,000 people experiencing homeless the entire year. I lived in Seattle for three years. It was possible to witness the scope of Seattle’s problem when walking their streets, any streets, really. From bus windows looking past I-5, you see tents. On Broadway Avenue, or 2nd Street, Or University Way there are people whose clothes, backpack, and overwhelming fatigue betray that they’ve spent the last week sleeping outside. The bushes of the park a couple blocks from my first apartment startled me when I realized there were people in them. The youth shelter at the bottom of the hill from my apartment had a long line of teenagers weaving out its door every evening. To my Rust Belt sensibilities, Seattle otherwise felt opulent, but I’d never seen so many people experiencing this privation before.

Portland declared emergency too, as did Los Angeles. I see this declaration for what it is: a tactic. Declaring a state of emergency entitles a municipality to additional funds to cope with a problem; here, it’s homelessness alleviation. It’s a rhetorical tactic, and it lands awkwardly. Homelessness is an emergency to the person experiencing it. (My employer gets many phone calls from people seeking shelter who, erroneously, think we are a service provider. I’ll take the few minutes to direct them to an organization that will help, which is usually a conversation with a polite stranger whose voice has hints of restrained panic.) Of course, an individual’s emergency doesn’t constitute a state of emergency for the entire municipality until the scope overwhelms. Leaders in these cities have decided that homelessness has left the realm of banal and into suffering so widespread that it cannot be ignored.

Homelessness is a consequence of capitalism, a human-made system. The way the market regulates prices on all things ensures that some people will go without. Some people will go without a job, as the market sorts skills and demand allows sought-after skills to command a high price and lower demand reduced ones. And the structure of the market determined that only people in certain circumstances (for instance, lacking a mental illness that impairs everyday function and perception of reality) will be able to participate. We decided, as a society, that you need money for housing, and if you don’t have the money, by and large you don’t have housing (but we are working on that; in WNY we’ve housed all but 37 people experiencing chronic homelessness(!)). Declaring a homeless state of emergency says, on some levels, we cannot tolerate the scope of our human-made consequences. That there are levels of homelessness that will tolerate, and now we’ve exceeded it. I’d prefer poverty and homelessness have perpetual urgency.

I know that the only solutions we currently have to homelessness have to be capitalism-compliant: we’re not providing guaranteed housing to everyone, we are stitching together a better safety net. This is a worthy endeavor (I do it for a living!), and I’m not knocking it. The state-of-emergency money will fund shelter beds and prevention programs. We’re fighting the consequences, not the causes. We’re not undoing the underlying assumptions of our economy. We’re not questioning the economy at all. We are just making it a bit less brutal to its inevitable victims. It’s the same line of thinking that treats poverty as a matter-of-fact constant in society. Courtesy of capitalism, that’s not inaccurate. Most states of emergencies are the consequence of forces of nature. We can’t redirect the wind, so we only deal with the consequences. This one is a consequence of our own economic system. Lost in the rhetoric of emergency is the structural role of our economy in creating this suffering. I wish we’d be so brave to see this, and braver still to effect change. As long as housing is a spoil of capitalism, we will be doing this work in perpetuity.

In any case, I wish Seattle, with Portland and Los Angeles, nothing but success in their efforts to diminish the suffering of people experiencing homelessness.

Comments Off on What does it mean when your state of emergency is a natural consequence of the economic system?

Filed under Class Warfare, Social Justice Commentary